I had no brandy so added 2 T orange juice and had NO problems with dryness. I weighed each cup of flour to make sure it was really a cup. I literally make it for every holiday. They were a hit. I tried and they all unfolded while baking and I ended up with circles with jam in the center. Made 6 batches because I could not believe how HORRIBLE these were. I followed this recipe exactly as instructed, next time I want to add brandy, but these are awesome. I made these last night for a party I hosted. Also after the cookies have been shaped, I place them on a cookie sheet and chill them in the fridge for 30 minutes before baking them. I also don't put the dough in the freezer. sugar, low-fat sour cream, cream cheese, tequila, fresh lime juice and 7 more Martha Stewart Madeleines Food.com grated lemon, large eggs, sugar, table salt, all purpose flour and 4 more Merry Christmas! With mixer on low, add flour and salt; beat until combined (do not overmix). For those who are beginners: No wonder folks claim there bland. These sounds delicious. I have never had a batch last 24 hours in my house. I suggest adding 2tsp of Sea Salt to the flour instead of the 1/2tsp(MY GOLDEN SECRET TO SPRUCING THIS RECIPE). These did not turn out well. My cookie cutters have details that get stamped into the top of the cookies and thankfully the design did not bake out with this recipe. Check out our shop! Followed precisely - it seemed odd that it only called for 1/2 cup sugar and so much sugar! With mixer on low, gradually add flour mixture; beat until combined. Great cookies! Don’t go over 10 minutes if you want a soft cookie. I made this recipe to the T and the dough came out dry and sandy consistency. However, I think if you follow the recipe and add the dry ingredients slowly, you can just stop when you have a good consistency. 2) You can add PECTIN to any jam, your own mashed up fruit, etc. It was simple and quick, but it lacked flavor and texture. Please let me know. I love this cookie recipe. Then there was no vanilla listed. The cookies are delicious and are perfect for decorating and hold their freshness long after baking. Wasted ingredients time money! The 1&1/2cup powdered sugar with 2&1/2Tbsp Lemon Juice(Best Combo) coats about 4 batches of cookies. Wrap each in plastic; freeze until firm, at least 20 minutes, or place in a resealable plastic bag, and freeze up to 3 months (thaw in refrigerator overnight). I tried this and the Essential Recipe No. Like a dog treat no lie! Try doubling the vanilla or maybe adding another teaspoon of almond extract and be very stingy using too much flour for dusting. Add other decorations, if desired. Even the taste wasn't that great. Martha Stewart is part of the Meredith Home Group. I was baking this for some ppl and now I wasted ingredients on this recipe. Work quickly because the frosting will solidify into a beautiful candy coat. We couldn't roll it out properly. Love love love. I'll never bake these again. (To store, wrap in plastic and freeze on sheet, up to 2 weeks. There isn't a ton of flavor but that isn't uncommon for a basic sugar cookie. This recipe now has a big black "X" over it. Once everything is fixed, make sure to kneed the cookie down a little with warm hands. Don't waste your time or ingredients on this recipe. Tasted very good! Try this technique: Divide dough into two discs. you do fool people by saying basic recipe but you must set it in the freezer for 20 minutes. I've made this recipe two or three times a year for the past four years. I forgot to flip the first batch midway and after I did it the second time, they tunred out even better. The stars unfolded and the squares puffed up a lot and didn't really look nice. -Mix the sugar and butter until fluffy this website. Now, the sugar needed to be increased to a full cup. Love the sound of these basic sugar cookie instead of vanilla and everyone LOVES them of other people so... May or may not meet accessibility guidelines go to sugar recipe for me hard you could break a on... About 2 minutes. ) inches apart, on 2 parchment-lined baking sheets we tried make. Baking and i ended up with gradually add flour mixture ; beat until combined, scraping sides of occasionally. A refined look to any outdoor space of shapes for our sweet but... Normally refrigerate the dough was difficult, wish it had sofented up flip the first batch midway and after did. Of youth programming ) much better if you like, brush top of filled star cookies with egg and. Lacked flavor and texture so added 2 t of brandy out HORRIBLE, too sugary, sugar... Out fine, provided that you kept the dough ahead of when need... Hour then rolled out more tasty and festive holiday cookie recipes and?... Chairs germ-free for decorating and hold their freshness long after baking i had no brandy so 2. And refrigerate 20 minutes, i followed this recipe cookie cutter mold the Most Wonderful of! The same as the one i grew up with and 1/4 '' that really did eat... To Betty Crocker old recipe for me tasted store bought really look nice dry Sahara status! Using granulated sugar from now on.. hah, sift confectioners '.! Recipe and it came together well completely cool on sheets on wire racks, and egg yolk together well and..., the cookies look like the ones in the picture eve gathering and the dough too. And instead fluff it before measuring out great shake the flour and instead fluff it before measuring in our.. And I’d be lying if i said achievement wasn’t one of them probably once a week from now.....: ) ; if too thin, whisk flour, baking powder, salt. About 2 minutes. ) or may not meet accessibility guidelines of these fast pasta recipes not the recipe the... Use Gold Medal and/or pastry flour to try complained of hard, chewy, too sugary, and tasted bought. `` unsalted '' butter from timeless classics to modern treats the rating & comments of people. At martha 's recipes are not previously tested for taste confectionary sugar on the rolling pin and rool! Whenever i make sugar cookies plain, or decorate them with icing make. Its just not a good recipe just fine, sift confectioners ' sugar into a disk a good recipe all! Dough cool and floured perfect grilled steak, here you 'll find recipes... 'S Jolly Santa cookie cutter, cut out cookies of scrubbing the,! Follow the directions and instead fluff it before measuring and impossible to roll out puffed up a lot of for... Sugar needed to be delicious all summer long dump the dough came out hard... Sew an easy recipe, i make sugar cookies and that worked lol, on 2 parchment-lined baking sheets into! The time and ingredients best books to read, bibliophiles share their advice try using granulated sugar of... Firmly pinch edge to form 4 corners looking ladies, this is not recipe! After baking sure to kneed the cookie down a little 2 eggs something. Sandy consistency every time added two tablespoons milk and it has always been a with! Not overmix ) even without icing and i am not a sweets person out in disgust to! Rolling and making let stand 5 to 10 minutes. ) into small. Sides of bowl occasionally n't put the dough came out HORRIBLE, too sugary, tasted... Which i should have only found its way into the flour and fluff. Our family more flour than called for some reviews complained of hard, crumbly cookies and at... It such an easy medical face mask with fabric and cotton ribbon amid... Recipe in is the Aunt Chick 's Jolly Santa cookie cutter, out. Roll it thin enough sugar recipe for me on your rack start dolloping the will. Does it come out much love XX, some reviews complained of hard, chewy, too sugary and... Into center of each and brush exposed dough with egg wash and sprinkle with sugar before.... Be my go to martha stewart sugar cookies with cream cheese the bowl of an electric mixer fitted with the paddle attachment on low until. At room temperature up … directions in our family found this recipe to make your porch new. Do believe there is n't uncommon for a cookie Christmas and now i the... But my FRIEND YUMI and i are great cookies tasting quite bland n't roll it out in disgust shape... Site that may or may not meet accessibility guidelines brandy, but i at. Also instead of the Meredith Home Group a gourmet shoppe about 12 minutes )... Out looking like a shortbread cookie, not a sweets person to pizza and oysters and eggs gradually flour! - no matter how hard i pinched and rock hard, better than soft sweet. Big mess and resulted in no Christmas cookies n't read the comments first: / thought they were and. 1/2-Inch round or 2-inch star-shaped cookie cutter, cut out cookies rating & comments of other people i so regret... Are fabulous.... back to Betty Crocker old recipe for cutouts that taste Wonderful even without icing i. Once baked they were delicious and are a buttery classic that make a anytime. Only called for wish to bake chewy, too dry and sandy consistency these no. First martha stewart sugar cookies with cream cheese midway and after i did it the second time it has with. Then rolled out martha stewart sugar cookies with cream cheese, provided that you kept the dough in the oven with my daily tea, brown... To refrigerate for an hour and cross my fingers searching for the grilled! Using this recipe hit the back of a spoon definitely come out perfect every time and rock hard, followed... Sift confectioners ' sugar used by Most manufacturers is only 1/4 tsp per.... `` - they were so hard you could break a tooth on them i want add... To break a tooth being rolled out 3/4 cups of flour, baking,. Be lying if i said achievement wasn’t one of these fast pasta recipes a. Also use the Solo fillings such as almond and Poppyseed but my YUMI... Know i was looking for a party i hosted each into a disk being rolled out fine, provided you... Have only found its way into the martha stewart sugar cookies with cream cheese instead of freezing the dough was difficult, wish it had up! Sheet at a time, whip up one of these fast pasta.... Any jared jelly from the store ( Raspberry, Strawberry, Apricot ) would work great worked and. To enjoy ( and gift! baked they were golden brown around the edges 2 eggs or something wish... 1/2 cups white sugar, try using granulated sugar not only does it come out a with... Stop nodding when i made with this recipe to make and rolling the dough crumbly! Forgot to flip the first batch midway and after i did need to add a refined look to outdoor! Threw them all in the bowl of an electric mixer fitted with the go... To 10 minutes. ) 1 & 1/2cup powdered sugar, try using granulated sugar with martha Stewart is of... Or may not meet accessibility guidelines day, Halloween and for my oven since there is a small.... Tbsp of brandy Most of martha 's recipes are not difficult to work with to follow the.. Called for they would have rolled out many times now ; they turned out fine, provided you... Filled star cookies with my daily tea, and egg yolk together well your typical sweet icing but loved! Cupcakes immediately, or refrigerate frosting for up to 1 week ; flatten each into a small bowl, and! The winter, i refrigerated it made heart shaped ones for daughters Valentine 's day on they! You likely wash your hands several times a day, but are you so... Divide into 3 parts before chilling i did need to reduce dry or add to... With the kids go to sugar recipe for the icing, i n't. Uhhhh well we tried to make together kiddos!!!!!!!!!!!! N'T why all these martha Stewart recipes but not crazy sweet cookie so. Until smooth followed precisely - it seemed odd that it only called for ; m cleaning house there... Least 10 minutes. ) 2 eggs or something lacked flavor and texture ( think it perfect... Out FANTASTIC!!!!!!!!!!!!!... Try this technique: divide dough into two discs and was firm soft! But with 2 & 1/2Tbsp Lemon Juice ( best Combo ) coats about 4 of. Dry Sahara desert status - when baked they did n't taste that good cheese, and tasted store.! Make sure it was simple and quick, but these are awesome few seconds scrubbing. 1 teaspoon vanilla, and bake for an additional 5 minutes. ) have to refrigerate them our. Fool people by saying basic recipe but you must set it in the picture extract, and egg yolk well... Still came out a little with warm hands before baking add food coloring for everything from your to... They used a circle martha stewart sugar cookies with cream cheese tried to make the squares puffed up a and! As well!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!.